Author
|
Topic: Number of Soviet Tank and Mechanized Corps
|
Chris Lawrence Moderator
|
posted 12-18-2002 12:50 PM
Can anyone clarify these seemingly contradictory counts:Zetterling, page 52 states "In July 1943 there existed 22 Tank Corps and 13 Mechanized Corps in the Red Army." Glantz, page 33 states "The basic building blocks of the Soviet armored and mechanized force were thirty-four tank and thirteen mechanized corps." The "Perechen: Obyedinenii i Soyedinenii Sovetskikh Vooruzhennikh sil..." (MHI 1992) shows 31 tanks corps and 12 guards tank corps. All 12 of those guards tank corps are shown raised from tank corps. It also shows 27 mechanized corps and 9 Guards Mechanized Corps. In this case, the list clearly included those from 1941. The first nine mechanized corps were formed a second time. There are also 9 Guards Mechanized Corps, one formed from a tank corps, five from the nine in the second formations of the mechanized corps (of which four also incorporated a tank corps), and three from rifle divisions. This would lead one to conclude that there were 31 Tank Corps raised and at least 13 (probably only 13) Mechanized Corps raised after 1941. Anyone know the source of the claim that 34 tank corps were raised (or does the statement "basic building blocks" somehow explain the different figures)?
IP: Logged |
craig Senior Member
|
posted 12-18-2002 12:59 PM
Chris,I don't have the material with me right now (it's at home) but I'll verify the numbers. Also, can you do me a favor and list the entire title of the "Perechen"? I'm also involved in a "Perechen" project and I'm wondering if it's the same list. Regards, Craig
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-18-2002 01:57 PM
From Sharp's work, Soviet Order of Battle, World War II, vol. II & III, there is the following information:- 31 tank corps were initially formed, but one (27th TC) was used as a cadre for 1st Mech Corps before ever finishing forming. So, actually 30 TC's were formed that saw combat. The last tank corps was formed in May 1943.
- Of those 30 TC's twelve went on to be designated GTC's. The last GTC formed was in November 1944. This means once all GTC's were formed there were 18 TC's and 12 GTC's.
- [edit!]There were 14 MC's formed. Five of them were formed from TC's - as well as a single partially formed TC (see No.1), but I'm not counting that instance. The last MC formed was in June 1945, roughly (10th MC). Soviet armored corps now stand at 13 TC's, 12 GTC's, and 14 MC's. After 6/42 it's 12 TC's, since 21st TC was never reformed after being destroyed at Kharkov.
- A total of 9 GMC's were designated, two from guards rifle divisions, one from a combination of a guards motorized rifle division and a mechanized brigade, and the remaining six from mech corps. The last GMC to be formed was in September 1944. This brings the total complement of Red Army armored forces at the end of the Soviet-German War to:
9 Guards Mechanized Corps 4 Mechanized Corps [edit!] 12 Guards Tank Corps 12 Tank Corps [edit!]
[This message has been edited by Greg LG (edited 12-18-2002).]
IP: Logged |
Chris Lawrence Moderator
|
posted 12-18-2002 03:01 PM
Craig, The full title is "Perechen: Obyedinenii i Soyedinenii Sovetskikh Vooruzhennikh sil, Vkhodivshikh v sostav deistvuyushchei armii v period velikom otechestvennoi voinyi 1941-1945 gg." It is published by the Institute of Military History, Moscow, 1992.
IP: Logged |
Chris Lawrence Moderator
|
posted 12-18-2002 03:13 PM
Greg, Thanks. So 30 or 31 Tank Corps and..... either 11 or 13 "post-1941" mechanized corps. Are you sure about those mechanized Corps? I've got nine Guards Mechanized Corps listed, and the following 2nd formation units: 1st Mechanized Corps 7th Mechanized Corps 8th Mechanized Corps 9th Mechanized Corps All four of these units have honorifics. [This message has been edited by Chris Lawrence (edited 12-18-2002).]
IP: Logged |
Chris Lawrence Moderator
|
posted 12-18-2002 03:20 PM
quote: Originally posted by Greg LG: ... but one (27th TC) was used as a cadre for 1st Mech Corps before ever finishing forming. So, actually 30 TC's were formed that saw combat.
Actually, on closer examination, one notes that the MHI (Military History Institute) book does not list the 27th Tank Corps, so we are indeed looking at 30 Tank Corps.
IP: Logged |
Chris Lawrence Moderator
|
posted 12-18-2002 03:25 PM
Haven't seen Sharp. Working backwards...I have 30 tanks corps by May 1943. Of those, three were used to form Guards Mechanized Corps by 23 June 1943 (28 TC, 13 TC, 14 TC). This leaves potentially 27 remaining tank corps, less any others lost or disbanded. So how do we get down to the figure of 22 existing in July 1943?
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-18-2002 03:54 PM
I noticed I missed a few details (and blew some basic math) from Sharp's volumes:
- When 21st TC was destroyed in June 1942 at Kharkov, it was never reformed.
- 13th MC was formed from 13th TC.
- 10th MC never saw action in the European theater only the Far Eastern theater against the Kwantung Army.
Thus, in May 1945 there were:9 Guards Mechanized Corps 4 Mechanized Corps 12 Guards Tank Corps 12 Tank Corps Given Sharp's research, in July 1943 there were 24 Tank Corps and 13 Mechanized Corps in the Red Army. In WWII, a total of 31 tank corps were formed. Of that number one was never fully formed before being incorporated into a mechanized corps, five were reformed into mechanized corps, twelve were later designated Guards units, and one was destroyed and never reformed. Of the mechanized corps there were a total of 14 formed, though one only saw combat in the Far Eastern theater. Of the fourteen, nine were later designated Guards units.
IP: Logged |
Chris Lawrence Moderator
|
posted 12-18-2002 04:37 PM
quote: Originally posted by Greg LG: 13th MC was formed from 13th TC.
The MHI book I have shows the 13th Tank Corps becoming the 4th Guards Mechanized Corps on 9 January 1943. quote: Given Sharp's research, in July 1943 there were 24 Tank Corps and 13 Mechanized Corps in the Red Army.
30 tank corps built by May 1943 (minus) 28th TC to 3rd Gds MC 18 Dec. 1942 (minus) 13th TC to 4th Gds MC 9 Jan. 1943 (minus) 14 TC to 5th Gds MC 9 Jan. 1943 (minus) 21st TC (Kharkov June 1942) = 26 The 8th TC and 22nd TC were converted to Mechanized Corps later.
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-18-2002 06:34 PM
quote: Originally posted by Chris Lawrence: 30 tank corps built by May 1943 (minus) 28th TC to 3rd Gds MC 18 Dec. 1942 (minus) 13th TC to 4th Gds MC 9 Jan. 1943 (minus) 14 TC to 5th Gds MC 9 Jan. 1943 (minus) 21st TC (Kharkov June 1942) = 26 The 8th TC and 22nd TC were converted to Mechanized Corps later.
I'm at work now, Chris, but if that's the case how do you account for the 13 mech corps by this time? There were only 14 total, the last one forming in 1945 for August Storm. There should only be 11 mech corps then in July 1943. [This message has been edited by Greg LG (edited 12-18-2002).]
IP: Logged |
Niklas Zetterling Senior Member
|
posted 12-19-2002 02:37 AM
This is how we arrived at 22 tank coprs and 13 mech corps (if I remember corretly, after all, it was some 4-5 years since we wrote the text):Tank corps 1st: Western Front 2nd: Southwest Front 3rd: Central Front 5th: Western Front 6th: Voronezh Front 9th: Central Front 10th: Steppe Front 11th: Moscow Military District 16th: Central Front 18th: Stavka reserve 19th: Central Front 20th: Moscow Military District 23rd: Southwest Front 25th: Stavka reserve 29th: Steppe Front 30th: Moscow Military District 31st: Voronezh Front 1st Gds: Bryansk Front 2nd Gds: Voronezh Front 3rd Gds: Steppe Front 4th Gds: Steppe Front 5th Gds: Voronezh Front Mech Corps: 1st: Steppe Front 2nd: Steppe Front 3rd: Voronezh Front 5th: Stavka reserve 7th: Moscow Military District 8th: Moscow Military District 9th: Volga Military District 1st Gds: Southwest Front 2nd Gds: South Front 3rd Gds: Steppe Front 4th Gds: South Front 5th Gds: Steppe Front 6th Gds: Moscow Military District
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-19-2002 03:57 AM
Chris,Regarding your source on 13th TC -> 4th GMC, Sharp may have solved the problem: "The 13th Mechanized Corps is an oddball in the Soviet Army. 13th Tank Corps had been so shot up that most of its tank brigades were removed in September-October 1942, and when Mechanized Brigades were substituted at the beginning of November, it should have been redesignated as a Mechanized Corps with a new number, as had happened to other tank corps in similar situations. Instead, the corps retained the number '13' and even the Soviet sources get confused on what to call it: a tank corps or a mechanized corps. It had the subordinate units of a mechanized corps when it went into battle in late November and December 1942. It fought as a mechanized corps with 57th, 51st and 2nd Guards Armies during December in the mobile battles against German panzers south of Stalingrad, and in recognition of its actions there on 9 January 1943 the 13th Mechanized Corps was redesignated as the 4th Guards Mechanized Corps." Subordinate units as of 1 November 1942 were: 17th Mechanized Brigade 61st Mechanized Brigade 62nd Mechanized Brigade 13th Tank Brigade 565th Antitank Regiment (20 45mm guns) 398th Antiaircraft Regiment (16 37mm guns) 214th Sapper Battalion Regarding 8th and 22nd TC's, Sharp shows that 3rd MC was formed on 18 September 1942 at Kalinin in Moscow Military District from 8th TC. If you doubt this, look up Katukov's memoirs: this was his unit to form. Sharp also places the date for 5th MC's formation in September 1942, forming from 22nd TC. This unit was involved in the fighting along the Chir in December 1942 against Balck's 11th Panzer Division, and was unique in being entirely armed with Valentines and Matildas of the 40mm gun persuasion.
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-19-2002 04:37 AM
Mr. Zetterling,The two tank corps you missed were from Rybalko's 3rd Guards Tank Army: 12th and 15th Tank Corps. 3rd GTA was in STAVKA Reserve as a separate unit at that time (1 July 1943). Chris, Incidently, on looking at the 1 July 1943 Soviet OOB provided by Sharp, he shows both 3rd and 5th MC's. They are part of Voronezh Front and STAVKA Reserves, respectively. Mr. Zetterling's source shows the same. [This message has been edited by Greg LG (edited 12-19-2002).]
IP: Logged |
Niklas Zetterling Senior Member
|
posted 12-19-2002 05:52 AM
quote: Originally posted by Greg LG: Mr. Zetterling,The two tank corps you missed were from Rybalko's 3rd Guards Tank Army: 12th and 15th Tank Corps. 3rd GTA was in STAVKA Reserve as a separate unit at that time (1 July 1943).
That's true. Thus 24 tank corps seems more realistic than 22.
IP: Logged |
craig Senior Member
|
posted 12-19-2002 07:22 AM
Chris,Thanks for the information. I concurr with the information provided in the previous messages. 24 Tank Corps 14 Mechanized Corps (1 HQ only) Craig
IP: Logged |
Rich Moderator
|
posted 12-20-2002 11:19 AM
All: please check this listing, I originally developed it for the Kursk project and have now corrected it with some of the information given here. Anybody who can give more complete formation dates would be welcome. By my count this gives the Soviets a total of 9 Guards Mechanized, 6 Mechanized, 12 Guards Tank, and 17 Tank Corps by the end of the war. Is that correct?Guards Mechanized Corps 1st Guards - from 1st Guards Rifle Division, November 42 2nd Guards - from 22nd Guards Rifle Division, November 42 3rd Guards - from 4th Mechanized Corps, December 42 4th Guards - from 13th Mechanized Corps, January 43 5th Guards - from 6th Mechanized Corps, January 43 6th Guards - from 3rd Guards Motorized Rifle Division and 49th Motorized Rifle Brigade, June 43 7th Guards - from 2nd Mechanized Corps, April 43 8th Guards - from 3rd Mechanized Corps, October 43 9th Guards - from 5th Mechanized Corps, October 44 Mechanized Corps 1st - from 27th Tank Corps, August 42 2nd - formed September 42; became 7th Guards Mechanized Corps, April 43 3rd - from 8th Tank Corps, September 42; became 8th Guards Mechanized Corps, October 43 4th - from 28th Tank Corps, October 42; became 3rd Guards Mechanized Corps, December 42, new 4th Mechanized Corps reformed July 43 5th - from 22nd Tank Corps, October 42; became 9th Guards Mechanized Corps, October 44 6th - from 14th Tank Corps, November 42; became 5th Guards Mechanized Corps, January 43 7th - formed September 42 8th - formed September 42 9th - formed September 43 10th - formed 1945 in the Far Eastern Theater (13th) – actually the reorganized 13th Tank Corps November 42, became 4th Guards Mechanized Corps, January 43 Guards Tank Corps 1st Guards - from 26th Tank Corps, December 42 2nd Guards - from 24th Tank Corps, December 42 3rd Guards - from 7th Tank Corps, January 43 4th Guards - from 17th Tank Corps, January 43 5th Guards - from 4th Tank Corps, February 43 6th Guards - from 12th Tank Corps, July 43 7th Guards - from 15th Tank Corps, July 43 8th Guards - from 2nd Tank Corps, October 43 9th Guards - from 3rd Tank Corps, October 43 10th Guards - from 30th Tank Corps, October 43 11th Guards - from 6th Tank Corps, October 43 12th Guards - from 16th Tank Corps, October 43 Tank Corps 1st - formed March 42 2nd - formed March 42; became 8th Guards Tank Corps, October 43 3rd - formed March 42; became 9th Guards Tank Corps, October 43 4th - formed March 42; became 5th Guards Tank Corps, February 43 5th - formed April 42 6th - formed April 42; became 11th Guards Tank Corps, October 43; new 6th Tank Corps reformed November 43 7th - formed April 42; became 3rd Guards Tank Corps, Jan 43; new 7th Tank Corps reformed November 43 8th - formed April 42; became 3rd Mechanized Corps, September 42 9th - formed May 42 10th - formed April 42 11th - formed May 42 12th - formed May 42; became 6th Guards Tank Corps, July 43 13th - formed May 42; became 13th Mechanized Corps, November 42 14th - formed May 42; became 6th Mechanized Corps November 42 15th - formed May 42; became 7th Guards Tank Corps, July 43 16th - formed June 42; became 12th Guards Tank Corps, October 43, new 16th Tank Corps reformed November 43 17th - formed June 42; became 4th Guards Tank Corps, January 43, new 17th Tank Corps reformed July 43 18th - formed June 42 19th - formed December 42 20th - formed December 42 21st – formation begun April 42 but never completed, destroyed at Kharkov June 42 and never reformed 22nd - formed April 42; became 5th Mechanized Corps, October 42 23rd - formed April 42 24th - formed April 42; became 2nd Guards Tank Corps, December 42, new 24th Tank Corps reformed July 43 25th - formed July 42 26th - formed July 42; became 1st Guards Tank Corps, December 42 27th - formed June 42; became 1st Mechanized Corps, August 42 28th - formed July 42; became 4th Mechanized Corps, October 42 29th - formed February 43 30th - formed February 43; became 10th Guards Tank Corps, October 43 31st - formed June 43
IP: Logged |
Chris Lawrence Moderator
|
posted 12-20-2002 12:10 PM
quote: Originally posted by Greg LG: Regarding 8th and 22nd TC's, Sharp shows that 3rd MC was formed on 18 September 1942 at Kalinin in Moscow Military District from 8th TC. If you doubt this, look up Katukov's memoirs: this was his unit to form. Sharp also places the date for 5th MC's formation in September 1942, forming from 22nd TC. This unit was involved in the fighting along the Chir in December 1942 against Balck's 11th Panzer Division, and was unique in being entirely armed with Valentines and Matildas of the 40mm gun persuasion.
Well that explains the discrepancy. The "Perechen" I am looking at show the 9th Gds MC created 10/23/43 from 3rd MC and 8th TC and the 10th MC created 9/12/44 from 5th MC and 22 TC. It does not show the genesis of the 3rd MC or the 5th MC and under the tank corps lists shows the 8th TC becoming the 8th Gds MC and the 22nd TC becoming the 9th Gds MC.
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-20-2002 12:43 PM
quote: Originally posted by Rich: All: please check this listing, I originally developed it for the Kursk project and have now corrected it with some of the information given here. Anybody who can give more complete formation dates would be welcome. By my count this gives the Soviets a total of 9 Guards Mechanized, 6 Mechanized, 12 Guards Tank, and 17 Tank Corps by the end of the war. Is that correct?
Rich, if you're counting the entirety of WWII, then by my count you are over by 1 Mech Corps, and 5 Tank Corps. Unfortunately, I won't be able to go over your list until tonight. Maybe Craig could do so before that. Incidently, Craig, are there plans for further additions to your OOB series from the Nafziger Collection?
IP: Logged |
Rich Moderator
|
posted 12-20-2002 02:06 PM
quote: Originally posted by Greg LG: Rich, if you're counting the entirety of WWII, then by my count you are over by 1 Mech Corps, and 5 Tank Corps. Unfortunately, I won't be able to go over your list until tonight. Maybe Craig could do so before that.
I think that is due to the supposed second formations of the 6th, 7th, 16th, 17th, and 24th Tank Corps and the 4th Mechanized Corps after the originals had been retitled Guards. Are you saying those corps did not have a second formation?
IP: Logged |
Anders E.Frankson Member
|
posted 12-20-2002 03:22 PM
HelloAs Niklas and I are for the moment looking the battles around Korsun Jan-Feb 1944 I notice on Rich´s listing that 3rd TC and 16th TC belonging to 2nd Tank Army has wrong information. Both these tank corps together with the Armycommand become Guards in November 1944. But their Guard designations are correct. Also that the designation of famous Tatsinskaya Corps (24th) which Balck trashed was re-used after the Corps become Guards is wrong according the information available to me. Anders Anders
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-21-2002 02:29 AM
Rich, I've highlighted any changes made, based on Sharp's information:Guards Mechanized Corps 1st Guards - from 1st Guards Rifle Division, November 42 2nd Guards - from 22nd Guards Rifle Division, October 42 3rd Guards - from 4th Mechanized Corps, December 42 4th Guards - from 13th Mechanized Corps, January 43 5th Guards - from 6th Mechanized Corps, January 43 6th Guards - from 3rd Guards Motorized Rifle Division and 49th MechanizedBrigade, June 43 7th Guards - from 2nd Mechanized Corps, July 43 8th Guards - from 3rd Mechanized Corps, October 43 9th Guards - from 5th Mechanized Corps, September 44 Mechanized Corps 1st - from 27th Tank Corps, September 42 2nd - formed September 42; became 7th Guards Mechanized Corps, July 43 3rd - from 8th Tank Corps, September 42; became 8th Guards Mechanized Corps, October 43 4th - from 28th Tank Corps, September 42; became 3rd Guards Mechanized Corps, December 42, no new 4th MC reformed afterwards. 5th - from 22nd Tank Corps, September 42; became 9th Guards Mechanized Corps, September 44 6th - from 14th Tank Corps, November 42; became 5th Guards Mechanized Corps, January 43 7th - formed January 1943 (was slow to form not being fully formed until September 1943) 8th - formed February 1943 (also slow to form, not fully formed until October 1943) 9th - formed January 43, but didn't become fuly formed until September 1943 10th - formed December 1944 in the Far Eastern Theater. Wasn't fully formed until June 1945 (13th) – actually the reorganized 13th Tank Corps November 42, became 4th Guards Mechanized Corps, January 43 Guards Tank Corps 1st Guards - from 26th Tank Corps, December 42 2nd Guards - from 24th Tank Corps, December 42 3rd Guards - from 7th Tank Corps, December 1942 4th Guards - from 17th Tank Corps, January 43 5th Guards - from 4th Tank Corps, February 43 6th Guards - from 12th Tank Corps, July 43 7th Guards - from 15th Tank Corps, July 43 8th Guards - from 2nd Tank Corps, September 43 9th Guards - from 3rd Tank Corps, November 44 10th Guards - from 30th Tank Corps, October 43 11th Guards - from 6th Tank Corps, October 43 12th Guards - from 16th Tank Corps, November 1944! Tank Corps 1st - formed March 42 2nd - formed March 42; became 8th Guards Tank Corps, September 43 3rd - formed March 42; became 9th Guards Tank Corps, November 1944 4th - formed March 42; became 5th Guards Tank Corps, February 43 5th - formed April 42 6th - formed April 42; became 11th Guards Tank Corps, October 43 (no new 6TC reformed) 7th - formed April 42; became 3rd Guards Tank Corps, December 42 (no new 7TC reformed) 8th - formed May 42; became 3rd Mechanized Corps, September 42 9th - formed May 42 10th - formed April 42 11th - formed May 42 12th - formed May 42; became 6th Guards Tank Corps, July 43 13th - formed April 42; became 13th Mechanized Corps, November 42 14th - formed May 42; became 6th Mechanized Corps November 42 15th - formed May 42; became 7th Guards Tank Corps, July 43 16th - formed June 42; became 12th Guards Tank Corps, November 44 (no new 16TC formed) 17th - formed June 42; became 4th Guards Tank Corps, January 43 (no new 17TC formed) 18th - formed June 42 19th - formed December 42 20th - formed December 42 21st – fully formed by the end of April 42, destroyed at Kharkov June 42 and never reformed [note: Interestingly enough, this unit began as 1st Mech Corps, but was redesignated 21TC by the end of April. This created confusion amongst it's parent unit, Southwestern Front command, as they seem to have not been aware of the new force structure developments. As a result, the 21TC was referred to as a mech corps for about a month] 22nd - formed April 42; became 5th Mechanized Corps, September 42 23rd - formed April 42 24th - formed April 42; became 2nd Guards Tank Corps, December 42 (no new 24TC formed) 25th - formed June 42 26th - formed July 42; became 1st Guards Tank Corps, December 42 27th - Began forming in June, but formation was never completed; became 1st Mechanized Corps, September 42 28th - formed July 42; became 4th Mechanized Corps, September 42 29th - formed February 43 30th - formed March 43; became 10th Guards Tank Corps, October 43 31st - formed May 43 Thanks to all for bringing this up. It added to my knowledge, anyway. [This message has been edited by Greg LG (edited 12-21-2002).]
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-21-2002 02:36 AM
quote: Originally posted by Rich: I think that is due to the supposed second formations of the 6th, 7th, 16th, 17th, and 24th Tank Corps and the 4th Mechanized Corps after the originals had been retitled Guards. Are you saying those corps did not have a second formation?
Thought I should address this directly as well. Yes, Rich, there is no indication of any tank or mech corps being reformed once an existing tank or mech corps was designated a Guards unit. I'm aware of this occurring quite a number of times with rifle divisions, but there's nothing I know of that even hints at this with tank or mech corps.
IP: Logged |
Anders E.Frankson Member
|
posted 12-21-2002 03:06 AM
removed[This message has been edited by Anders E.Frankson (edited 12-21-2002).]
IP: Logged |
Greg LG Senior Member
|
posted 12-21-2002 05:55 AM
quote: Originally posted by Anders E.Frankson: Hello Greg Just a minor detail. On 9th Guards Tank Corps You missed changing the Year to 1944, thus it should read november 1944. You made the change correctly on 3rd Tank Corps.Anders
Thanks, Anders. I knew I'd miss something.
IP: Logged |
Rich Moderator
|
posted 12-21-2002 10:30 AM
quote: Originally posted by Greg LG: Thought I should address this directly as well. Yes, Rich, there is no indication of any tank or mech corps being reformed once an existing tank or mech corps was designated a Guards unit. I'm aware of this occurring quite a number of times with rifle divisions, but there's nothing I know of that even hints at this with tank or mech corps.
Thanks Greg, I had always been suspicious of that, but had never gotten around to double checking. Thanks for the corrected formation dates as well. So does that summarize the information pretty thoroughly then - and does anyone want to make a stab at the evolution of the original Mechanized Corps and the Rifle Divisions?
IP: Logged | |